#Blogtour: Not Thomas by @SGethinWriter #review #giveaway @BrookCottageBks @honno

By | July 24, 2017

Every so often, a book comes along – without any great fanfare – that makes me want to shout about it from the rooftops. Not Thomas by Sara Gethin – published by the consistently excellent Honno Press on 15th June – is one of the most stunning books I’ve read this year. As I finished reading, I immediately nominated it for the Guardian Not The Booker prize – if there is any justice in this world (and I do hope there will be) this book should be on mainstream prize shortlists everywhere. I’m just so thankful that Sara chose a blog tour with Brook Cottage Books to help bring it to people’s wider attention. Had she not, it might have passed me by entirely… and what a loss that would have been.

Tomos lives with his mother. He longs to return to another place, the place he thinks of as home, and the people who lived there, but he’s not allowed to see them again. He is five years old and at school, which he loves. Miss teaches him about all sorts of things, and she listens to him. Sometimes he’s hungry and Miss gives him her extra sandwiches. She gives him a warm coat from Lost Property, too.

There are things Tomos cannot talk about – except to Cwtchy – and then, just before Easter, the things come to a head. There are bad men outside who want to come in, and Mammy has said not to answer the door. From behind the big chair, Tomos waits, trying to make himself small and quiet. He doesn’t think it’s Santa Claus this time.

When the men break in, Tomos’s world is turned on its head and nothing will be the same again.

I’ve mentioned before that I’m not a big fan of reading about the ugliness of this world, drug culture, violence, neglect – but that’s the world you’ll find in this book, and I couldn’t tear my eyes away. And if you’d told me that I’d sit, totally rapt, reading a book written in the voice of a five year old child, seeing that dreadful world through his eyes and from his unique perspective – well, I really wouldn’t have believed you.

I could do with a thesaurus to come up with some new adjectives – the best ones have all been used. Let’s try powerful, moving, heart-wrenching, poignant, shocking, emotional, enthralling, and maybe a bit exhausting – but let’s not forget uplifting, life-affirming, and sometimes wonderfully funny too.  The impact of this book was exceptional.  Tomos’ voice is absolutely authentic and compelling: you find yourself smiling at the way he expresses himself, immediately before being in tears at some new piece of cruelty that he dismisses as the norm. The detail of his world becomes part of yours – the borrowed coat, the damaged truck, the coin, the black chair – and long after finishing reading, those small details will stay with you.

Standing back from the story and its content a little, the mechanics of story-telling are superbly handled – overheard adult conversations, not always fully understood by Tomos, move it cleverly forward and disentangle the threads around past history and the adult relationships. The story itself is strong, with real narrative drive and unexpected twists and turns – much more than an unflinching view of a suffering child.

There’s a whole range of humanity in this book – exceptional generosity, love and kindness sitting alongside ignorance, cruelty and neglect. And you’re left with that aching feeling that someone should have seen what was happening and intervened more forcibly – and then wondering how many other children might be suffering in a similar way.

The author, in one of her blog posts, says of the reader: I hope… their mouths will have smiled, as Tomos might say, even if their eyes have cried. That summed this wonderful book up absolutely perfectly for me. A unique and unforgettable experience – and one I’d urge everyone not to miss.

Let me share an extract…

The lady’s here. The lady with the big bag. She’s knocking on the front door. She’s knocking and knocking. And knocking and knocking. I’m not opening the door. I’m not letting her in. I’m behind the black chair. I’m very quiet. I’m very very quiet. I’m waiting for her to go away.

I’ve been waiting a long time.

‘Thomas, Thomas.’ She’s saying it through the letter box.

‘Thomas, Thomas.’

I’m not listening to her. I’m not listening at all. She’s been knocking on the door for a long long time. I’m peeping round the black chair. I’m peeping with one of my eyes. She’s not by the front door now. She’s by the long window. I can see her shoes. They’re very dirty. If Dat saw those shoes he’d say, ‘There’s a job for my polishing brush’.

She’s stopped knocking. She’s stopped saying ‘Thomas’. She’s very quiet. The lady can’t see me. I’m behind the big black chair. And I’ve pulled my feet in tight.

‘Thomas?’ she says. ‘Thomas?’ I’m not answering. ‘I know you’re in there. Just come to the window, sweetheart. So I can see you properly.’

I’m staying still. I’m not going to the window. I’m waiting for her to go back to her car. It’s a green car. With a big dent in it. If I hide for a long time she’ll go. She’ll get back in her car and drive away. She’s knocking. And knocking again.

She’s saying ‘Thomas.’ And knocking and knocking again.


That is not my name.


With thanks to Sara Gethin, Honno Press and Brook Cottage Books, I’m delighted to be able to offer the chance to win a copy of Not Thomas – 3 e-copies (open internationally) & 3 paperbacks (UK only). Here’s the rafflecopter for entry:

a Rafflecopter giveaway

About the author

Sara Gethin is the pen name of Wendy White. She grew up in Llanelli and studied theology and philosophy at Lampeter, the most bijoux of universities. Her working life has revolved around children – she’s been a childminder, an assistant in a children’s library and a primary school teacher. She also writes children’s books as Wendy White, and her first, Welsh Cakes and Custard, won the Tir nan-Og Award in 2014. Her own children are grown up now, and while home is still west Wales, she and her husband spend much of their free time across the water in Ireland. Not Thomas is her first novel for adults.

Facebook | Twitter | Blog | Website 

25 thoughts on “#Blogtour: Not Thomas by @SGethinWriter #review #giveaway @BrookCottageBks @honno

  1. Carol Lovekin

    Perfect review, Anne. I still can’t think about this very special book without having ‘a moment.’ xXx

    1. Anne Post author

      Thanks Carol – it was just stunning! And what a great eye for special books your wonderful publisher has… xx

  2. Karen Cole

    What a fabulous review! Thank you for drawing my attention to what sounds like a very special book!

  3. Sara Gethin

    Thank you for your lovely review, Anne, and for entering Not Thomas into the Guardian’s Not the Booker prize – I appreciate it very much.

    1. Anne Post author

      An absolute pleasure Sara – you’ve written a very special book…

      1. Sara Gethin

        Oh thank you, Anne. It turned into a labour of love – only fourteen years in the making!

  4. Thorne Moore

    You can’t compare this book with any other. You just have to read it down in one bite and let it eat through your innards. If it does’t win Not the Booker Prize, there’s something wrong.

    1. Sara Gethin

      Yes, Anne has written a lovely review, hasn’t she? Will take a look at your blog, El.
      Sara x

  5. jessiecahalin

    I saw this book in Cardiff today and noted that there were not many copies left. The book does look tempting. Thanks for this insight.

  6. Wendy Janes

    What a wonderful review. Must add this book to my to-read list.

    1. Sara Gethin

      Thank you, Wendy. Yours looks really intriguing too – I’ve seen the cover on twitter. Will be adding it to my TBR list.
      Sara x

      1. Wendy Janes

        Super! Thank you, Sara. Hope you enjoy it.

  7. Judith Barrow

    A wonderful review for a wonderful book. This is one of the most moving and exceptional novels I have ever read. A Not the Booker Prize winner for sure.

    1. Sara Gethin

      Thank you for your lovely comments, Judith – I think you were one of the first people to read it!

Comments are closed.